Longtime Westchester Italian restaurant, in business since the '70's, is closing

A longtime Westchester red sauce restaurant is closing and, according to comments on Reddit, it's all due to the expiration of a lease, rising rent costs and the fact that the owners (and kitchen staff) are ready to retire.

While the owner of Francesco's didn't give a reason, he did say the restaurant, which has been in White Plains since the '70s, will close sometime next week.

The dining room at Francesco's. The restaurant, which closes this month, feels like a time warp with its old-school booths and tables. Photographed June 20, 2024.
The dining room at Francesco's. The restaurant, which closes this month, feels like a time warp with its old-school booths and tables. Photographed June 20, 2024.

The unassuming Italian eatery known for its legendary chicken parm, is like a throw-back in time— complete with two candy machines at the bar, vintage signs, black and white photos, and old-school sports memorabilia with signed posters from former New York Rangers players and other ice hockey stars.

More: Two more Westchester restaurants closing doors in June. What will replace the eateries?

Also popular: It's thin-crust pizza, made in a stone-bottom gas oven, as well as other traditional recipes.

Rob Pastore of Pleasantville is one customer who always appreciated the old school vibe and classic Italian menu. "It's a throwback and a place you knew you'd get a good meal," said Pastore, who's been coming to the restaurant for close to a decade. "The pizza is excellent, so is their chicken parm and the baked clams."

White Plains resident Dawn Priore is another fan who laments their closing. "When I moved to White Plains 27 years ago, my husband and I ate there when we got engaged, brought our kids there as babies, had family get togethers, and ordered take-out pizza once our lives got too hectic."

Originally from Brooklyn, she said Brooklyn pizza didn't compare once she tasted Francisco’s pie with fried eggplant. "It's like nothing I ever had growing up in the city," she said.

Even now, so close to Francesco's end, she's wondering how to cram in her pizza fix.

"My 18-year-old daughter and I tried to figure out if there's a way to learn from the owners how to make the pizza or what it would take to buy as many pizza pies as I can to freeze them," she said.

"It's like mourning the loss of a relative once you frequent a place like this."

Francesco's, an old-school Italian restaurant, in White Plains since the '70s, is closing. Photographed June 20, 2024
Francesco's, an old-school Italian restaurant, in White Plains since the '70s, is closing. Photographed June 20, 2024

Know of an opening or closing?

Email JRMuchnick@gannett.com with restaurant news.

Jeanne Muchnick covers food and dining. Click here for her most recent articles and follow her latest dining adventures on Instagram @jeannemuchnick or via the lohudfood newsletter.

This article originally appeared on Rockland/Westchester Journal News: Francesco's in Westchester, in business since 1970s, to close